734-359-7018
Now Accepting New Clients!
Blog

PROBATE 32: Can you file a breach of fiduciary duty complaint for a disagreement related to the estate?

Plaintiff filed this action against defendant, who is the personal representative of the estate of plaintiff’s father.

Plaintiff’s father died on June 17, 2015. Following his death, estate proceedings were initiated in Washtenaw Probate Court, and defendant was appointed by the court as personal representative of the estate.  The only significant asset was a residential property in Ann Arbor, Michigan.

While the estate proceedings were ongoing, in November 2016, plaintiff filed a separate complaint in Washtenaw Circuit Court claiming that she held a mortgage and promissory note on the home; plaintiff sought to foreclose on the property and quiet title in her name. The circuit court property dispute was transferred to the probate court and consolidated with the estate proceedings.

Notably, on August 8, 2017, the judge entered an order concluding that plaintiff had not shown that she was entitled to enforce the note and mortgage that was in her possession, which had been given by her father to his parents. The judge held plaintiff failed to demonstrate she had personally acquired any rights under the note and mortgage. Accordingly, the judge rejected plaintiff’s request to foreclose and to quiet title to the property in her name.

On May 16, 2017, while the consolidated estate and foreclosure proceedings were still pending, plaintiff filed in the probate court a complaint alleging 17 counts against defendant in her capacities as an individual, as personal representative of the estate, and as attorney for the personal representative of the estate.

In an October 26, 2017 order, the trial court granted summary disposition to defendant on all of plaintiff’s claims except for two. The trial court permitted plaintiff’s action to proceed on her claims of breach of contract and unjust enrichment (Counts I and II), and these claims were only allowed to proceed against defendant in her capacity as personal representative. Following a bench trial, the judge entered judgment in favor of defendant, concluding that plaintiff had failed to establish her claims for breach of contract and unjust enrichment.

The common theme of these claims was that plaintiff disagreed with various actions taken by defendant related to the estate and such actions therefore constituted a breach of defendant’s fiduciary duty. Plaintiff cites no authority for the proposition that her mere disagreements with the decisions of defendant as the personal representative establishes that defendant breached her fiduciary duty.

Defendant had a duty to act in the best interests of the estate, MCL 700.3703(1). However, plaintiff argued that defendant’s fiduciary duty was to accede to plaintiff’s precise demands and make decisions about matters involving the estate that were in accordance with the outcomes plaintiff desired. Clearly, this is not the nature of a personal representative’s fiduciary duty.

The claims for breach of fiduciary duty in plaintiff’s first amended complaint contain no allegations, beyond plaintiff’s mere subjective and conclusory assertions of disagreement with defendant’s decisions, as to how any of defendant’s actions were legally improper such that they constituted a breach of fiduciary duty.

Aldrich Legal Services represents clients in a wide range of probate litigation matters.

Given the emotional nature of these disputes and their financial impact on all involved, it is critical that anyone involved in such a dispute retain highly qualified legal counsel.

Contact Aldrich Legal Services

Basic responsibilities of an executor

Originally posted on 01/11/2017 The emotional toils of dealing with the death of a loved one can be considerably difficult. Nevertheless, perseverance is paramount; especially if you are appointed to be an executor to one’s...

What you need to compliment your will

Originally posted on 02/08/2017 Making end-of-life plans usually end with a will, but they shouldn't. Some believe that simply having a will is enough. However, this post will briefly explain how having other estate planning...

The benefits of home health care providers

Originally posted on 03/22/2017 As we get older or suffer an injury, we need a little extra help. Home health care providers or caregivers can provide the assistance needed to handle your or your loved one's health and safety...

What to know about bail conditions

Originally posted on 03/06/2017 If you have been arrested and are being held on the suspicion that you have committed a particular crime, chances are that the only thing you are thinking about is getting out of jail as soon as possible and...

College students and estate planning

Originally posted on 12/16/2016 With college semesters starting up in Michigan, it may not be so easy to get college students to think responsibly. This time can be especially tough with the need of moving back to school and getting...

Three reasons to put a power of attorney in place

Originally posted on 11/08/2016 While no one wants to think of the unfortunate possibility of being incapacitated or of a time when we can't handle our own affairs, this circumstance is a real possibility. If something happens and this...

How to approach parents about estate planning

Originally posted on 12/09/2016 Family forms a strong foundation for many people's first and most intimate community. It is important to strengthen these first relationships so even uncommon questions become natural. For those...

PROBATE 44: Petition for Mental Health Treatment

Michigan’s Mental Health Code governs the civil admission and discharge procedures for a person with a mental illness. Specifically, MCL 330.1434 sets forth the procedure and content requirements for a petition for mental health treatment.

Should you get your criminal record expunged?

Originally posted on 04/12/2017 If you have been convicted of a crime, have served your sentence, and have followed all court recommendations, you should be able to put your past behind you and move on with life. Moving forward is critical...

Choosing the right executor for an estate

Originally posted on 05/28/2017 When people are thinking about planning their estate, they often think about trying to minimize the estate tax, keeping their will updated, and keeping items out of probate court; however, there is another...

Understanding how the Miranda warning works

Originally posted on 11/25/2016 Michigan residents who have seen television police shows or movies involving law enforcement have no doubt watched many dramatic scenes with officers quoting something to the effect of, "You have the...

Don't let a bad decision, unfair contract, or a messy divorce get in the way of a promising future!
Contact the experienced team at Aldrich Legal Services today to schedule your free initial
consultation
and secure reliable and trustworthy representation today!
Get the Help You Need From a Team You Can Truly Count On: (734) 404-3000
734-237-6482
734-366-4405