734-359-7018
Now Accepting New Clients!
Blog

FAMILY LAW 25: Plaintiff granted attorney fees incurred in attending unnecessary hearings.

The parties have joint legal custody of the minor child. Initially, the parties agreed to joint physical custody and no child support. Beginning in September 2014, defendant was awarded primary physical custody. Plaintiff was granted parenting time mid-week and on alternating weekends. The parties’ relationship has been fraught with acrimony and poor communication. The Friend of the Court conciliator recommended that the parties participate in family and individual therapy with the goal of reducing the parties’ hostility towards one another. Defendant refused to participate, claiming that it was not in his or the child’s best interests.

Beginning in 2015 through 2018, defendant filed several unsuccessful motions attempting to restrict plaintiff’s parenting time. In March 2018, defendant filed a motion seeking sole legal custody, as well as a reduction of plaintiff’s parenting time and to have her parenting time supervised. The trial court treated the motion as a motion for reconsideration of a ruling it had earlier made on parenting time issues and denied the motion, noting that defendant had not established palpable error but had merely presented the same issues.

Defendant argued that the trial court did not comply with MCR 3.210(C)(8) before denying his motion to modify custody and parenting time, and that he established proper cause or a change in circumstances sufficient to warrant a best interest hearing.

MCL 722.27(1)(c) provides that a trial court may modify or amend a child custody order for proper cause shown or because of change of circumstances if doing so would be in the best interests of the child. In the context of a motion seeking a change in custody, to establish a proper cause, the movant must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that an appropriate ground for legal action exists, which should be relevant to at least one of the twelve statutory best interest factors and of such magnitude as to have a significant effect on the child’s well-being.

As the moving party, defendant was required, as a threshold matter, to first demonstrate to the trial court either proper cause or a change of circumstances before the court could proceed to an analysis of whether the requested modification is in the child’s best interests. An evidentiary hearing is required before custody can be changed, but the preliminary determinations whether proper cause or change of circumstances allows further consideration does not necessarily require an evidentiary hearing.

In this case, the record shows that defendant’s motion to modify custody and parenting time was premised primarily on allegations that had been repeatedly raised and reviewed by the court. In December 2015, Child Protective Services promptly investigated defendant’s complaint and found that plaintiff’s house was clean and appropriate for minor children. CPS informed defendant that his repeated calls and complaints against the Plaintiff-mother, in which there was not a preponderance of evidence to support the complaint, are ‘counting against him’ at this point.

Ultimately, the trial court granted plaintiff reasonable attorney fees incurred in attending four unnecessary hearings and awarded her additional parenting time to make up for the times wrongfully denied by defendant.

If you are going through a divorce or are separating from the mother or father of your children, it is important to protect your custodial rights. Seek the guidance of an experienced family law and divorce attorney who will be by your side every step of the way.

At the Plymouth and Ann Arbor law firm of Aldrich Legal Services, our attorneys represent parents throughout southeast Michigan with a wide range of custody-related matters.

Contact Aldrich Legal Services

 

Basic responsibilities of an executor

Originally posted on 01/11/2017 The emotional toils of dealing with the death of a loved one can be considerably difficult. Nevertheless, perseverance is paramount; especially if you are appointed to be an executor to one’s...

What you need to compliment your will

Originally posted on 02/08/2017 Making end-of-life plans usually end with a will, but they shouldn't. Some believe that simply having a will is enough. However, this post will briefly explain how having other estate planning...

The benefits of home health care providers

Originally posted on 03/22/2017 As we get older or suffer an injury, we need a little extra help. Home health care providers or caregivers can provide the assistance needed to handle your or your loved one's health and safety...

What to know about bail conditions

Originally posted on 03/06/2017 If you have been arrested and are being held on the suspicion that you have committed a particular crime, chances are that the only thing you are thinking about is getting out of jail as soon as possible and...

College students and estate planning

Originally posted on 12/16/2016 With college semesters starting up in Michigan, it may not be so easy to get college students to think responsibly. This time can be especially tough with the need of moving back to school and getting...

Three reasons to put a power of attorney in place

Originally posted on 11/08/2016 While no one wants to think of the unfortunate possibility of being incapacitated or of a time when we can't handle our own affairs, this circumstance is a real possibility. If something happens and this...

How to approach parents about estate planning

Originally posted on 12/09/2016 Family forms a strong foundation for many people's first and most intimate community. It is important to strengthen these first relationships so even uncommon questions become natural. For those...

PROBATE 44: Petition for Mental Health Treatment

Michigan’s Mental Health Code governs the civil admission and discharge procedures for a person with a mental illness. Specifically, MCL 330.1434 sets forth the procedure and content requirements for a petition for mental health treatment.

Should you get your criminal record expunged?

Originally posted on 04/12/2017 If you have been convicted of a crime, have served your sentence, and have followed all court recommendations, you should be able to put your past behind you and move on with life. Moving forward is critical...

Choosing the right executor for an estate

Originally posted on 05/28/2017 When people are thinking about planning their estate, they often think about trying to minimize the estate tax, keeping their will updated, and keeping items out of probate court; however, there is another...

Understanding how the Miranda warning works

Originally posted on 11/25/2016 Michigan residents who have seen television police shows or movies involving law enforcement have no doubt watched many dramatic scenes with officers quoting something to the effect of, "You have the...

Don't let a bad decision, unfair contract, or a messy divorce get in the way of a promising future!
Contact the experienced team at Aldrich Legal Services today to schedule your free initial
consultation
and secure reliable and trustworthy representation today!
Get the Help You Need From a Team You Can Truly Count On: (734) 404-3000
734-237-6482
734-366-4405