Now Accepting New Clients!

REAL ESTATE 54: Can amendments to condominium bylaws change rights of owners?

This case concerns the enforceability of an amended condominium bylaw prohibiting short-term rentals where such rentals had been expressly contemplated and allowed under an existing 15-year contract between the owner of a condominium unit and a property management company.

The bylaw in effect when the contract was executed had permitted short-term rentals of 14 days or more, and the contract essentially incorporated the bylaw, authorizing the property management company to lease the condominium unit for periods as short as 14 days. The amended bylaw required a minimum rental term of four months, effectively precluding the property management company from leasing the unit to typical vacationers.

Original Bylaws

Pertinent to this case, the bylaws had originally provided that no Co-Owner shall lease his unit for a term less than fourteen (14) days nor shall any Co-Owner lease or rent less than an entire unit in the condominium and that the requirement of a minimum 14-day rental period also applied to a Co-Owner who places his unit on rental management.

Property Management Contract

In December 2013, Defendant purchased a condominium unit in the development. Defendant then constructed a 5,600 square-foot, single-family home on the property. In his deposition, Defendant agreed that he had reviewed the master deed and the bylaws before buying the property; however, he did not speak to any board members before the purchase.

On June 23, 2015, after having constructed the home on the property, Defendant signed a 15-year contract with CRA authorizing CRA to manage the property in relation to future rentals. The Agreement provided that Defendant was leasing his condominium unit to CRA for the 15-year period.

After executing the CRA contract, Defendant e-mailed the document to the condominium board for review and approval. Defendant claimed that the board approved the CRA contract. The board, however, supplied an affidavit that reflected the contrary.

Amendment to Bylaws

In June 2016, the board began the process of amending the bylaws to prohibit short-term rentals. Upon obtaining the consent of two-thirds of the co-owners and mortgagees, the board amended the bylaws in November 2016 to now prohibit co-owners from leasing their condominium units for terms of less than four months.

Defendant, through counsel, sent the board a letter asserting that the amendment did not apply to Defendant because the board could not legally invalidate an existing lease agreement such as the one that he had signed with CRA.

Court Decision

In May 2018, the trial court issued a written opinion and order granting summary disposition in favor the Board Members.

In general, the master deed, bylaws, and condominium subdivision plan may be amended, even if the amendment will materially alter or change the rights of the co-owners or mortgagees, with the consent of not less than 2/3 of the votes of the co-owners and mortgagees.

But MCL 559.190(2) is tempered by MCL 559.212(1), which provides, as noted earlier, that while a condominium association may amend condominium documents as to the rental of condominium units or occupancy terms, the amendment shall not affect the rights of any lessors or lessees under a written lease otherwise in compliance with this section and executed before the effective date of the amendment.

The court held that the CRA contract constituted a property management agreement, not a lease agreement; therefore, the exception to the general enforceability of bylaw amendments found in MCL 559.212(1) was not implicated in this case.

Skilled Legal Assistance with Condominium Associations

Aldrich Legal Services offers comprehensive real estate services to meet the legal needs of homeowners, commercial property owners, investors, real estate developers and other parties with real estate interests in Michigan.

Contact Aldrich Legal Services

Speak to a Pro: (734) 404-3000

FAMILY LAW 50: A Michigan Court has jurisdiction to make an initial custody determination when it is the home state of the child on the date of the commencement of the proceeding or within 6 months before the commencement of the proceeding.

PROCEDURAL HISTORY  Plaintiff and defendant have twin sons, but never married.  On August 13, 2008, the Court of Common Pleas Juvenile Division in Montgomery County, Ohio established plaintiff as the legal father of the children and...

When You Should Contest a Will?

Wills usually go through without a problem. Well over 90% of wills have no issue making it through probate. However, there are several grounds you may have to contest a will. As a beneficiary, or someone who would gain from a will, there are legal...

What You Need to Know About Distracted Driving

A great U.S. freedom is the ability to drive the open roads. However, every year there are more than 20,000 car accidents in Michigan. Many of these accidents come from distracted driving and could have been avoided. Distracted driving is such a...

Reasons Your Will or Trust Could be Contested

Everyone reacts in their own way when a family member passes away. Emotions can run high, and people can react more strongly than they normally would. Some family members may feel cheated by what a will or trust grants them leading them to contest...

Penalties For Driving Without Insurance in Michigan

Getting into a car and going for a drive isn’t perfectly safe. Driving on the Michigan roads can be dangerous. Driving those same roads becomes financially dangerous if you drive without car insurance. Between fees, charges, and possible...

PROBATE 36: Undue influence to execute Lady Bird deed.

This probate dispute between siblings arises out of the death of their father. Their father lived alone. In 2013, however, he asked appellee to live with him. She agreed, moving into the home in August 2013. Appellants allege that in the years...

Top 5 Most Common Traffic Violations in Michigan

Staying safe on the roads is in everyone’s best interest. However, keeping yourself or others out of danger is everyone’s responsibility. Getting a traffic ticket ends up costing drivers big time. Traffic tickets and citations cost money...

Don't let a bad decision, unfair contract, or a messy divorce get in the way of a promising future!
Contact the experienced team at Aldrich Legal Services today to schedule your free initial
and secure reliable and trustworthy representation today!
Get the Help You Need From a Team You Can Truly Count On: (734) 404-3000